15 Lessons from 15 Years of Dividend Growth Investing

Fifteen years into dividend growth investing, Mike looks back on the lessons that shaped his strategy, his portfolio, and his mindset. This episode is a practical reflection on what actually matters over the long run: having a process, avoiding common traps, managing risk with intention, and focusing on business fundamentals instead of noise.

From early investing mistakes to the evolution of the Dividend Triangle, this is a strong recap of the principles that helped him stay consistent and get ahead of his original plan.

Subscribe to our Free Weekly Newsletter!

You’ll Learn

Psychology and mindset matter more than most investors think

A big part of long-term success has nothing to do with predicting the market. It comes from accepting that you will make mistakes, staying confident in your process, and refusing to let emotions drive decisions.

You can’t be right 100% of the time, but you can be 100% confident in your process.
Investors must humble themselves because no one is smarter than the market for very long.
Macro noise, political headlines, and economic fears often distract investors from what really matters.
Hope is not an investment strategy; portfolio decisions need to be grounded in clear rules.
Avoiding paralysis by analysis starts with simple, practical buy and sell rules.

Mike explains that clarity removes hesitation. The stronger your process, the easier it becomes to act with conviction instead of second-guessing every move.

Dividend growth investing worked because it matched the investor

One of Mike’s biggest realizations was that the best strategy is not necessarily the “best” on paper. It is the one you can follow consistently for years.

After years of margin investing, trading, and even dabbling in penny stocks, Mike found dividend growth investing through the Dividend Guy Blog and recognized its appeal:

It required less time than active trading.
It brought more structure and discipline.
It offered a mix of performance and lower volatility.
It aligned with his life as a planner, business owner, and parent.

This episode is a reminder that strategy fit matters. A good strategy should help you sleep at night and make it easier to stay invested through all kinds of markets.

Portfolio management is where discipline shows up

Stock picking gets a lot of attention, but portfolio management is what keeps a strategy effective over time. Mike shares several lessons about managing positions, risk, and expectations more intentionally.

Don’t confuse patience with complacency.
Eliminate insignificant positions that consume time but won’t move the needle.
Sector rotation sounds smart, but it is often just another form of prediction.
Let winners run, but trim them when they become too large for your risk tolerance.
Create your own dividend when needed instead of obsessing over yield.

One of the strongest messages here is that total return matters more than how cash reaches your account. Selling shares can be part of a sound retirement income plan, just like dividends.

Stock selection should balance narrative and numbers

Mike admits that one of his biggest mistakes came from letting a strong story overpower weak financial metrics. That lesson led him back to a more disciplined analysis process.

Don’t let the narrative override the numbers.
If a company’s revenue, earnings, and cash flow trends are weakening, the story alone is not enough.
Looking for the bear case can help reduce emotional bias and prevent overconfidence.
Falling in love with a stock can blind you to warning signs.

This section highlights how important it is to challenge your own thesis, especially when you feel most excited about an investment.

Investors should stop obsessing over yield and entry points

Several lessons in the episode challenge popular habits among dividend investors. Mike makes the case for becoming more flexible and more focused on quality than on surface-level metrics.

Ignore the all-time high bias; a stock at a high can still deliver strong long-term returns.
Become yield agnostic and focus instead on dividend growth, payout ratios, and business quality.
Valuation is context, not a trigger.
There is no perfect buy price based on one neat formula or target.

The broader message is that rigid yield rules and valuation targets can cause investors to miss great businesses. What matters more is understanding the company, its growth profile, and how it fits within your process.

The Dividend Triangle remains the core framework

Mike closes the episode by reinforcing the foundation of the DSR approach: the Dividend Triangle. It is his preferred way to simplify analysis while still focusing on what matters most.

Revenue growth
Earnings-per-share growth
Dividend growth

He explains this as the Pareto principle in action: a small set of key metrics can deliver most of the insight needed to evaluate a business. It is simple, efficient, and highly effective for long-term investors.

Know what you own and why you own it

The final takeaway ties everything together. Investors should never hold stocks just because they are going up or because others are buying them.